smoked pot roast

Not your Momma’s Pot Roast Recipe

Nothing says down home cooking like a pot roast. I know growing up at my house we had pot roast for dinner at least once a month. Typically pot roast is prepared either in a crock-pot or roasting pan in the oven, but I’m taking it outdoors to the smoker. Pot Roast for me is Beef. Any cut of beef can be used, but the cheaper cuts tend to make the best pot roast. The cut I use is called Chuck Roast. The Chuck Roast has plenty of extra fat which gives the meat more flavor and it stands up well to long braising times. smoked pot roast For this recipe I bought a 3lb Chuck Roast which is more than enough for a family meal. The first step is to season the meat. I used my AP seasoning to create a base coat of flavor. AP Seasoning:
  • 8oz Salt
  • 4oz Granulated Garlic
  • 2oz Ground Black Pepper
Dust the outside of the roast with a good coat of the AP seasoning. I also add a layer of Montreal Steak seasoning because I like the flavor it brings to beef. Montreal is a great final layer for any cut of beef on the grill. I use it on brisket, steaks, or any red meat. smoked pot roast rub Let the roast sit for a few minutes, so the seasoning has time to work on the meat. Meanwhile it’s time to fire up the Ugly Drum Smoker with a basket of charcoal and a good chunk of pecan wood. Pecan produces a mild smoke that goes great with beef. It doesn’t take much at all. smoked pot roast on smoker Once the cooker hits 250 it’s time for the chuck roast to hit the grill. It goes right on the rack above the hot coals. Allow it to cook, so it browns on both sides (not charred) and it takes about 30 minutes per side. This also gives the meat time to absorb the pecan smoke. smoked pot roast While the meat is smoking, I mixed up a braising liquid of concentrated beef base and water. You can find similar products on the soup isle in your local grocery store. The brand I used came from Restaurant Depot; it’s called Empire’s Royal Au Jus base. Beef Base can be used for Soups, Stocks, or Sauces but it makes a great braising liquid. Add 1/8 cup of the base to 48oz of boiling water and whisk. It’s simple to put together and it brings a ton of flavor to the roast. Once the meat is browned transfer it into a ½ size Aluminum pan and add enough braising liquid to come up about ½ way on the meat. I also added 1 cup of Red Wine to the liquid to fortify the flavors. To add even more “pot roast” flavor I topped the roast with 1 packet of Lipton Onion Soup Mix. smoked pot roast Cover the pan with aluminum foil and return it to the smoker. You can’t have pot roast without vegetables, but don’t add them right away. The roast needs an hour head start; if you add the vegetables too soon, they’ll overcook. I like to use onions, potatoes, and carrots but feel free to add your favorites here. Mushrooms, Celery, Whole Green Beans, or anything that can stand up to a long cook time works great. Once the vegetables are added to the pot roast, cover the pan and continue to cook for 2 more hours. Keep the heat consistent (250 degrees) and kick back. smoked pot roast After two hours, check the roast for tenderness. I don’t worry with a meat thermometer at this point. It’s all about being “fork tender”. When the roast falls apart with the twist of a fork it’s done. The broth is infused with the smokiness of the meat and the vegetables soak up all the goodness. You’ll want to make sure they’re fork tender too. Bring the roast inside and transfer it to a serving platter. It doesn’t hurt to let it cool for a few minutes because it will be extremely hot. Ladle some of the beef jus/drippings over the roast and vegetables to keep everything moist and the remainder is used for making brown gravy. You can’t have pot roast without rice and gravy! smoked pot roast To make the gravy melt 3 Tablespoons of Real butter in a sauce pan. Add 2 Tablespoons of flour and whisk for 1 minute over medium heat. Pour in 2 cups of the Au Jus whisking constantly. It will thicken as it comes to a boil. Remove from the heat and serve. Pot Roast will never be the same once you’ve had it on the smoker! Malcom Reed Connect on Facebook Follow me on Twitter Subscribe to my YouTube Channel Find me on Google+ Follow me on Instagram Buy Killer Hogs Products Here

Have a Question About This Recipe?

Connect with us in our HowToBBQRight Facebook group for recipe help, to share your pictures, giveaways, and more!

9 responses to “Not your Momma’s Pot Roast Recipe”

  1. Brian Crass says:

    I’ll be using a 2lb roast. would you change the cooking times? Brian

  2. Michael Spangler says:

    I’m not sure what I did wrong. Followed all the directions, except I used only beef broth instead of beef base and did not include the red wine. When I took the meat off the cooker (used a pellet grill) it was still tough.

    • Malcom Reed says:

      If it was still tough, it didn’t get cooked long enough. Make sure you get it tender before removing it from the cooker – it’s not just about time when your cooking on the grill

  3. Mike Landry says:

    Damn Malcolm, that sounds so good! I love a good pot roast and that recipe looks great!

  4. Richard Henderson says:

    Turned out fantastic Malcolm! My only suggestion would be to extend the cook out an hour or two before adding the veggies, I was shooting to eat at 1930 so I began the 4.5 hours earlier and the flavor was there but the meat needed more time. Got up this morning and cooked it a little more in the oven and now it’s perfect.

  5. Sterling Derrick says:

    Without a doubt, the absolute best pot roast I have ever had – and I’ve had a lot of pot roast in my 75 years!

  6. Cara says:

    When cooking on a Traegar would you use the same amout of browning/cooking time?

  7. Sky Tate says:

    I did this a few months ago and it was awesome. Going to do it again today. I used a dutch oven instead of the tin pan.

  8. Jim says:

    Sorry Malcom but this was a miss. 3.5lbs. Eight hours on the smoker and if was not breaking down. Eight hours at 250 degrees. If you attempt this recipe, start is before breakfast and hope it is ready for a late dinner and have a place to order out just in case.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.