Ribeye Sandwich

Bonafide Ribeye Sandwich Recipe

Bonafide Ribeye Sandwich Recipe

Just when you think a ribeye steak couldn’t get any better….I’m going to turn you on to the “Ribeye Sandwich”. But this just isn’t any old, ordinary steak sandwich… I use choice ribeye steaks grilled to perfection; top them with sautéed sweet onion, baby portobello mushrooms, and melty provolone cheese – all served on Texas garlic toast with a roasted garlic mayo. Ribeye Sandwich For the ribeyes I use an 8-10oz choice grade steak. It gets tenderized (for this I used an onion slicer but you can use a jacquard) since we’re leaving it whole on the sandwich; and it’s meant to be picked up and eaten – not cut with a knife and fork (but you fancy folk could use utensils is you like). The steaks are seasoned with salt and pepper and then drizzled with Worcestershire and Balsamic Vinegar. Rest them on the counter until ready to cook (about 45 minutes). Ribeye Sandwich For this cook I fired up my Weber Kettle for this cook using a chimney of Royal Oak briquettes for fuel. Once the coals are hot, dump them on one side of the grill and place an aluminum pan on the cool side to create a 2 zone fire. I also used a set of Grill Grates for those steakhouse grill marks. Ribeye Sandwich As soon as the grill heats up, place a cast iron skillet on the hot side and add 1 Tablespoon of Olive Oil and 1 Tablespoon of Butter. Toss in the veg and season with a good pinch of Salt and Black Pepper – along with a few good dashes of Worcestershire. The vegetables will take about 10 minutes to brown and softened. When done, move the skillet over to the cool side. Ribeye Sandwich Now it’s time for the steaks. Season the steaks with Killer Hogs Steak Rub  on both sides and place on the hot side of the grill. Cook for 2 minutes – rotating half way if you want to create grill marks. Flip the steak over with a Grill Grates tool and repeat. Ribeye Sandwich Next place the steaks on a flat iron skillet and top with the onions and mushrooms. Lay a couple slices of provolone cheese over the top and let the cheese melt for about 30 seconds. Ribeye Sandwich Once the provolone melts, remove the skillet from the grill and let’s build a sandwich! Ribeye Sandwich For the bread I’m going with thick cut Texas Garlic Toast. Then slather each slice with Roasted Garlic Mayo and place the Steak on the toast. Add the other slice of bread to the top and you have a Bonafide Ribeye Sandwich! Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
Ribeye Sandwich

Bonafide Ribeye Sandwich Recipe


  • 2 Ribeye Steaks (8-10oz each)
  • 1 sweet onion (sliced thin)
  • 8oz Baby Portobello Mushrooms (sliced)
  • 4 slices Provolone Cheese
  • 1/4 cup Worcestershire Sauce
  • 1 Tablespoon Balsamic Vinegar
  • 1 Tablespoon Killer Hogs Steak Rub
  • Kosher Salt & Black Pepper
  • Texas Garlic Toast* (recipe below)
  • Roasted Garlic Mayo* (recipe below)

Texas Garlic Toast

  • 4 slices thick cut Texas Toast
  • 1/2 stick Butter
  • 1 teaspoon Dried Parsley
  • 1/2 teaspoon Garlic Powder
  • Preheat oven to broil setting. Place butter, parsley, and garlic in a small bowl and heat in microwave for 30 seconds. Stir to combine and brush on top side of each piece of toast. Place the toast in the oven for 1-2 minutes or until brown.

Roasted Garlic Mayo

  • 1 head of roasted garlic (about 10 cloves)
  • 1 cup Mayonnaise
  • 1 teaspoon Cracked Black Pepper
  • 1 teaspoon Killer Hogs Hot Sauce
  • Place the roasted garlic cloves in a small bowl. Mash with a fork until a paste. Add the remaining ingredients and stir well to combine. Store in the refrigerator until ready to serve.


  1. Fire up charcoal grill for 2 zone grilling
  2. Tenderize steaks, season with Salt & Black Pepper, Drizzle with Balsamic Vinegar and Worcestershire Sauce.
  3. Place cast iron skillet on hot zone of grill grate. Add 1 TBS each Olive Oil and Butter.
  4. Add onions and mushrooms to skillet, season with salt and black pepper; drizzle with Worcestershire Sauce. Cook for 10 minutes until brown and tender.
  5. Season each steak with Killer Hogs Steak Rub and place on the hot zone of the grill.
  6. Cook for 2 minutes each side or until rare – medium rare.
  7. Top each steak with onions and mushrooms; layer on 2 slices of provolone cheese; and let melt on the grill for 30 seconds.
  8. Slather each piece of Texas Garlic Toast* with Roasted Garlic Mayo*; Place steak on toast and top with the other slice.
Malcom Reed Connect on Facebook Follow me on Twitter Subscribe to my YouTube Channel Follow me on Instagram Buy Killer Hogs Products Here

Have a Question About This Recipe?

Connect with us in our HowToBBQRight Facebook group for recipe help, to share your pictures, giveaways, and more!

8 responses to “Bonafide Ribeye Sandwich Recipe”

  1. Jim says:

    Look great .. looking forward to receiving more information!!!

  2. Mr Cuisine says:

    It’s Jaccard a Jacquard is not used in cooking but in the textile industry. But come on you make fun of people using utensils why can’t you simply say that thing that looks like it’s got a bunch of needles in it and pokes holes in the meat.

  3. Brian McEndree says:

    I made these the other day……Bonafied sammich! Delicious..Thank you

  4. Jason Magallanez says:

    One of the best Ribeye sandwiches I’ve ever made! Thanks Malcom!!

  5. SNOWSER says:

    U Da Man Brother / EPIC SAMMICH ?????

  6. Mike Medwin says:

    Just made it, unbelievable Sammie! Malcom delivers again!

  7. Larry Dodd says:

    Hi Malcolm, I enjoy all your recipes very much , just trying to figure out what your meaning by a 2 side aluminum pan cook

  8. ArtyJ says:

    Ribeye is way too fatty to use a whole piece, untrimmed. I’d trim it, slice it and lay it on the bread and them melt the cheese.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe rating 5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.